Tuesday, 9 June 2009
8th and 9th June, editing/ talking/ FILM NIGHT
Monday, 1 June 2009
27th May and 1st June, Planning and testing!
Monday, 25 May 2009
25th May, WKW films!
Wednesday, 6 May 2009
6th may, Viewing Blanche, feedback, montage and screenplay
Blanche
- Snappy, interesting beginning
- Appropriate music
- Slow pace during the chase scene
- Unclear plot
- Dragged on
- Obvious song loop (accidental double song)
- Good sound intensifying (getting louder)
- Strange transition between loud music and back to house scene - relevance unclear
- Bad ending shot
I think that honestly I have improved tremendously in film. Although people may not have thought this was as good as the last project that my group worked on, Plunge, Jeff was the 'initiator' of what went on during that film. This film was very much in Julien's and my hands. I am actually quite proud of myself. Of course it could have been improved, but I think it was a good effort. A note for next time; snappiness must be kept in mind at all times! I mentioned this in my last evaluation, and I tried to keep that in mind. However I think some of the scenes were storyboarded so that it was actually impossible to keep them snappy (not enough angles/footage to choose from). I think I should also keep in mind the time allotment. An issue with this film was lack of time. To be honest though, that is not a real excuse as we knew from the beginning how much time we were given. I was quite happy with the sound, as I was sound editor, (apart from that single ANNOYING added section that got into it), and I think that I did actually learn a lot from this project, even though I didn't manage to work on the sound on SoundTrack Pro properly.
After the film viewing, of which Blanche was the only film shown, we learnt a bit about our new project. Not only is it going to be focused around Wong-Kar Wai, but it is also going to include montage editing. Montage is a type of film style that is put in during post-production. The editor puts in certain shots after certain shots, so as to make the viewer feel certain things. These shots may or may not be events that are supposed to be happening at the time. There are 5 levels of montage:
Metric - Cutting is given a specified number of frames, and cuts to the next shot regardless of what is happening. This invokes the most primal emotional reactions in the viewers
Rhythmic - Cutting is also based on time, but it generally alludes to more complex meaning, and uses different shot speeds (i.e. sped up shots). Montage can also include audial elements (music, dialogue, sounds) - 'Rhythmic sound'.
Tonal - Rather than just having the film with metric and rhythmic cutting, other symbolic shots are put in to elicit emotional meanings more complex.
Overtonal - Overtonal montage is a cumulation of metric, rhythmic, and tonal montage to synthesize its effect on the audience for an even more abstract and complicated effect.
Intellectual - This uses shots which, combined, elicit an intellectual meaning. This also uses symbolic shots, but of a more powerful and metaphorical nature. The meaning can only be derived when these shots are juxtaposed with the original footage.
Eisenstein, Sergei; Jay Leyda (translator) (1942). 'The Film Sense'. Harcourt Brace and Company. OCLC 01289114.
Learning about these was actually very interesting, as although I never knew it was a type of editing style, I have seen in used many times. During class I was an inquirer (see below), because I remained focus and attentive throughout the presentation of the new topic that we were learning about. I was especially interested in the examples, of which there were several, and asked questions regarding what type of montage certain excerpts used.
We were also given a task to complete for next class; to find and draw inspiration from a picture for a Wong kar-Wai-esque screenplay. The picture that I have chosen is the following:
http://images-2.redbubble.net/img/art/size:large/view:main/567607-3-memory-does-not-make-films-it-makes-photographs.jpg
I like this photo because it is very sparse, and although usually a photo like this would be boring, there is something about the colors and atmosphere that I really like. I plan to write a screenplay about someone falling in love on public transport. I know that doesn't sound particularly Wong Kar-Wai like, yet, as I have not watched enough of his films, again 'yet', however it will hopefully work. It will be a very 'mundane' sort of screenplay, with little dialogue, and hopefully lots of scenery- and montage, of course. I think I will settle for the most simple type of montage, 'metric'
Inquirers: Develop their natural curiosity. They acquire the skills necessary to conduct inquiry and research and show independence in learning. They actively enjoy learning and this love of learning will be sustained throughout their lives.
Open-minded learners: Understand and appreciate their own cultures and personal histories, and are open to the perspectives, values and traditions of other individuals and communities. They are accustomed to seeking and evaluating a range of points of view, and are willing to grow from the experience.
Monday, 4 May 2009
4th May, Viewing films, feedback
Through this exercise, and during the commenting (after the films), I was a reflective learner, a thinker and a communicator (see below). I was reflective in the fact that I noted in other films the parts that I had found particularly difficult (such as color correction), which I will at some point ask the group who made the film about. This will aid me in supporting my own weakness(es) by doing something about them. I was a thinker because I was quite critical of other films, and using my own creativity and reasoning gave constructive criticism that could be of use were the groups to edit the films some more. Finally, I was a communicator because I was able to get my ideas and thoughts on the film across both politely and loudly, through words and hand motions (another 'mode' of communication...body language!). During the films I took some notes, and I took noes on what others fed back on during the commenting period. Below is a summary.
Say Cheese
- Comical music at the beginning takes the edge off and gives it the wrong 'feel'
- Strange/ unrelated beginning... made me confused later on as to Sarah's part in the film
- Fast paced music, but too fast before action catches up
- Sometimes unclear what is happening
- Some interesting/original shots i.e. 'eye' opening and closing and running into camera
- Not enough portals
- Background 'buzzing' ambient noise obvious at some points
- Suspenseful ending
- Nice idea that could have been expanded
Babooshka
- Well-done, suspenseful beginning
- Obvious red-tint; camera alteration and editing obvious
- Continuity sometimes disregarded; person is in one place, then another withOUT portals
- Nice parallels between music and visuals (i.e. when Xiang yi jumps and the heavy music starts)
- Music is not a clear indicator as to what is going on - strangely heavy
- Mostly good background sound, until running on courts and footsteps
- End is unclear as to what happened
Wabbit Hunt
- Nice beginning music
- Very good idea - although not 'original', very good choice for portal project, and they made it their own
- Tastefully done transition between speaking and no speaking - appropriate
- Some obvious sound input (editing obvious)
- Very loud scream - a bit distracting and out of place
- Funny playground scene, but it goes on a bit too long
- Running sounds where previously there was not supposed to be any diagetic sound
- Strange transition to bus out of school - obvious change in pace that ruined the illusion a bit
- Dragged on slightly
- Very funny and entertaining
High Octane
- A bit quiet
- Some obvious sound editing - creaking noises put it
- Some nice angles - feet running away on steps
- Very nice 'sped up' style (from brick)
- Strangely comical fight scene - bit inappropriate (sped up style made it funny and weird)
- Music a bit strange for content - made me unsure what to feel
- Very high production value - a pleasure to watch
Reflective learners: Give thoughtful consideration to their own learning and experience. They are able to assess and understand their strengths and limitations in order to support their learning and personal development.
Thinkers: Exercise initiative in applying thinking skills critically and creatively to recognize and approach complex problems, and make reasoned, ethical decisions.
Communicators: Understand and express ideas and information confidently and creatively in more than one language and in a variety of modes of communication. They work effectively and willingly in collaboration with others.
Film Review: As tears go by

- a film by Wong Kar-Wai
Directed By: Wong Kar-Wai
Written By: Wong Kar-Wai
Released in: 1988
Starring: Andy Lau and Maggie Cheung
Genre: Crime/ Drama
The story follows a Kowloon-dwelling triad brother, Wah, inn his day-to-day life that consists mostly of bailing his 'little brother', Fly, out of trouble with the big guys. Amidst this temperamental scene, Wah's cousin comes to stay, and they in turn fall into a love affair complicated by Wah's triad life.
She has the power to change his life, but after Fly's promise to assassinate a squealer to up his rep, Wah has no choice but to leave his cousin forever and help his friend once and for all.
http://shangols.canalblog.com/images/As_Tears_Go_By_Aff3.jpg
A brilliant piece of cinematography. This was my first proper experience of a 'Wong Kar-Wai' film, and although I am not completely familiar with what makes it unique (yet!), I have to say that I thoroughly enjoyed it, despite the language divide. At first glance, the characters are shallow and meaningless, but through great shots and interesting occurrences, they turn out to be captivating. As aforementioned, the shots and filming style added a lot to the film. Though they sometimes seem unconnected, such as the first shot of the film with the rows of television screens, they help to set up the correct atmosphere to put the viewer into the right frame of mind. Harsh, abrasive colors gave me a sense of what triad-strewn Kowloon might have been like, whereas the disjointed cuts (point of view, thoughts, where character is) show what the character is thinking and feeling while keeping up the interest of the viewer.While watching this film I noticed a number of cinematography styles, and I learnt some new ones. One of these was a type of montage, where clips that were not necessarily related, or in the same vicinity, are linked together to create a certain feeling. This was especially the case when Wah dies at the end, and he gets a flash from the past of the phonebooth kissing scene with his cousin. This was really effective at making the audience sympathize with him, as they are reminded that he is human. It also let them know that he was definitely dying, as that could have been a cause for confusion. Another style of film that I noticed was where the scene was slowed down. However it was not only slowed down, as that is simply slow-motion; it had a certain, strange, quality to it. Julien told me that this is something called undercranking (I think that is what it is called), where the film is captured at a slower frame rate, so that it looks slower, but sped up. This method was used a lot, particularly during the fight scenes. This really have the viewer time to pay attention and realize what was going on, while at the same time be able to fully take in all the action. I really liked this, as while it maintained the illusion of belief, it 'mixed it up' and kept the viewer interested.
Overall, a very intriguing film.
Wednesday, 29 April 2009
29th April, Not viewing the films, Closer (!) and editing!
Monday, 27 April 2009
27th April, Exporting and self-assessments!
Wednesday, 22 April 2009
22nd April, Sound editing/ logging/ editing/ planning!
- Causeway Bay - we need to completely re-shoot the traffic scene, as in our original it is pretty obviously night time, which it is not supposed to be in the film
- My house - for the bedroom scene, which has been such a pain to film as we have had trouble finding suitable locations AND for the extra bathroom scene, so that it makes the transition between the food court and the bathroom more like a portal
- Juliens house - to re-film some roof scenes, in which there were papers in the shot (don't ask me why)
Monday, 20 April 2009
20th of April, Soundtrack Pro/ Recording/ Planning/ Editing!
Wednesday, 8 April 2009
8th of April, logging/ editing/ planning and film title!
Monday, 6 April 2009
6th April, Logging/ filming and planning!
- Redo of Julien getting into taxi
- Park'n'shop
- Wing on
- Roof
Monday, 30 March 2009
30th of March, Reviewing 'Plunge' and Planning!
Plunge
- It dragged on a lot, with slow dialogue (acting could have been better)
- Transitions and cuts could have been 'snappier' to increase the pace
- The structure was not appropriate for the length of the film; the voice-over introduction set it up for a much longer piece and gave some unnecessary information
- Some audio problems i.e. different noise levels between cuts, brought down the production value a bit
- Could have been more sounds (phone buttons being pressed)
- Production value was overall quite high - :)
I also learnt a new word:
Diagetic Sound;
A sound that is created by something or someone visible on the screen or whose source is implied to be present by the action of the film. Non-Diagetic sounds are “added” sounds like music and voice overs.
and a new term:
Production Value;
A method, material, or skill used in the production of a motion picture; the technical quality of such a method, material, or skill.
http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/production_value
Thinkers: Exercise initiative in applying thinking skills critically and creatively to recognize and approach complex problems, and make reasoned, ethical decisions.
Communicators: Understand and express ideas and information confidently and creatively in more than one language and in a variety of modes of communication. They work effectively and willingly in collaboration with others.
Film Review: Kung Fu Hustle

- From walking disaster to kung fu master
Directed by: Stephen Chow
Written by: Stephen Chow and Xin Huo
Released on the 23rd December, 2004
Starred in by: Stephen Chow, Yuen Wah, Yuen Qiu and Chan Kwok Kuen
Genre: Action, Comedy, Fantasy
Set in Canton, China in the 1940s, the story revolves around a town ruled by the Axe Gang. The protagonist (of sorts), called Sing, desperately wants to become a member. He stumbles into a slum ruled by eccentric landlords who are actually kung-fu masters in disguise. Sing's actions eventually cause the Axe Gang and the slumlords to engage in an explosive kung-fu battle. Sing turns out to be a kung-fu natural himself, and in the end gets everything he had ever hoped for.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0373074/
Originally I decided to watch Kung Fu Hustle because I had heard that it was a very funny Chinese film, and I wanted to both have a good time and practice my Chinese. I had no idea it would be the out-there, crazy adventure that it turned out to be! First of all I had to put on English subtitles, as I could not properly understand it all in Chinese. Then came the crazy plot; superhuman powers, impossible acts...it was full of everything that I do not associate with Chinese films. In my opinion it was a very Baz Luhrmann type film (like Moulin Rouge), rich in visual material, from crazy slow-motion scenes, to sped up running (like the cartoon type - legs going around in circles) and strong sounds. The plot was a bit poor, and kept jumping from story to story, so it wasn't entirely clear who the protagonist was until closer to the end, nor what the point of the film was.
The most interesting aspect of the film was definitely editing. The footage was very well put together, and had the right balance of close-ups interlaced with moving shots, even if it was all a little crazy. There were also some very interesting shots and ways of showing certain scenes. In a scene where someone gets punched in the face, rather than showing the punch, the screen gets punched and 'blood and flesh' are splattered onto the lens, which really gave me as a viewer the sense of being punched.My favorite film happens to be Moulin Rouge, however that is more for the plot than the way that it is edited (although that adds to it too!). However despite the fact that Kung Fu Hustle was similar in style, and that it was very well done for the crazy type of film that it is, I'm not entirely sure how much I liked it. It is for sure that this is a one-off in Chinese cinema, and definitely a must-see for those who are tired of the average rom com/tear jerker/ superhero film!
Wednesday, 25 March 2009
25th March, Reviewing films!
Natalia
- Some out-of-place shots that disoriented the audience
- Obvious changes in ambient light and sound
- Several faulty match-on-action shots
- Broke the 180 degree rule
- Quite slow (pace-wise), as well as lacking in flow
- No clear focus or aim in the film
- Nice closing shot, zooming out of the protagonist - shows how small he feels
- Dragging pace and slow transitions (pause between dialogue = unnatural)
- Some out-of-place shots (car keys being thrown) ruins the flow
- A couple of good match-on-action transitions - should have done more with that
- Some very obvious fade-in fade-outs; the 'waiting' scene was also strange, not only unsuitable for the theme of the film but also the camera work was quite jog-y, which was obvious when the scenes were cut into each other
- Nice 'drunk' effects - out of focus and jog-y
- A couple of strange black screens
- Continuity error with the gun
- Broke the 180 degree rule
- Songs could have been played throughout
- Gritty room was a bit out of place
- Lighting was different in every location - did not flow well
- Flashback in black and white was too cliche
- Happy song with phone was out of place
- Nice closing scene - black screen 'don't wait up for me tonight'
Looking at these notes, I know that they are mostly all negative, however I feel like before I can even think about trying to produce a 'knock-out' film, it is important first to get the basics down and to eliminate all amateur mistakes. Most films made the same type of mistakes - mostly with match-on-action shots that don't flow, strange sound and innapropriate shots. In the films however there were also some elements that I really liked. The dream-like quality of 'The Broken Beautiful' had a really big impact. Watching these films also gave me new ideas into possible concepts I could incorporate in upcoming film projects, such as having a recurring track or symbol, using shots that literally show how the protagonist is feeling and keeping cuts to a certain time (possibly speeding them up).
Today I was definitely a reflective learner (see below), as I took into consideration all the aspects of editing that were being critiqued so that our next project can avoid that (even though I am sound editor in this one). I see the mistakes that I made reflected in other people's work, and during our discussion I now know what it is exactly that editing needs to bring to the project. It is not solely a matter of stringing shots together; it creates the mood and flow of the entire peace, ultimately 'making or breaking' it. During this project I will definitely work closely with our editor (Jing Ting) so that we don't risk making the same mistakes again.
Even though we were not working in our current film groups today, as sound editor I tried to take note of what could be improved sound-wise in other peoples films. When I actually get round to doing the sound editing, I will definitely go to Mr.Chiang and Ms.Wong for help when I need it - a concept that actually never really occurred to me, as I had previously planned to simply look up sound editing techniques online. I noticed that the main errors with other films were the change in ambient sound from shot to shot. The narration also sounded strange when it was on its own, as it was clearly filmed in a silent room; no background noise is very unnatural. As we have narration in our upcoming film, I will have to remember to film in a natural environment (preferably on location). I feel like I got a lot from this class, but I can't wait until next class, to see what people have to say about ours!
Reflective learners: Give thoughtful consideration to their own learning and experience. They are able to assess and understand their strengths and limitations in order to support their learning and personal development.